I am looking for information/ideas about how to teach my child phone etiquette. Is that even the right term? What I mean is, how to have a phone conversation with another human.
Do I remember learning how to use the phone? No, I do not. I am guessing that I learned it through emulating my parents. You answered the phone a certain way, you handled the call a certain way, you closed the call a certain way. Those were all things I probably absorbed just from living in my house.
But… How do you teach a child how to use the phone when you can’t teach by example?
My house as an adult is nearly phone free. AS I PREFER, of course. We have no landline. My husband and I each have a cell phone, but we both actively avoid phone calls. I talk to maybe three people on the phone on a regular basis. I call my mom once or twice a week. I call my best friend from back home once or twice a month. And then there’s a mom from school who is a Phone Fan and who calls me, on average, once a week or so.
I do have phone meetings with clients, as well. But those are infrequent and tend to cluster.
All of these phone calls take place, almost without exception, when Carla is in school. Sure, sometimes I am still talking with my mom when I pick up Carla from school. Sometimes the mom friend calls when I am at home with Carla. But those instances are rare. The VAST MAJORITY of all of my human interactions take place via text or in person.
(This is the third time I’ve used the word human in this post; I deleted one of the instances, so you are only seeing two of them. Well, now three since I used it again just a second ago. What is the deal? Am I subconsciously worried that you might think I’m spending time talking to… cats? Birds? The deer in my yard?)
Back to the subject at hand: I wish I could just wiggle dismissive fingers at the whole idea of talking on the phone. By the time Carla’s old enough to want to communicate with her friends outside of school, she will probably want to text them or snapchat them or whatever it is young people do these days.
Be that as it may, being able to talk on the phone is a SKILL. A dying one, perhaps. But one that could come in handy in Carla’s future professional life and at the very least is useful now when talking to her very patient grandparents. (I have a full-body cringe thinking about my poor mom saying, cheerfully, “Hello? Carla? Are you still there?” when Carla has CALLED HER and then given up on the call halfway through, with no heads-up to my mother.)
My parents wind up being the guinea pigs for phone calls, by the way. And I am sure that the conversations are as frustrating on their end as they are on my end (where I am gesturing to Carla to pay attention and stop doing a backbend off the couch and answer the question your grandfather just asked you). But how does a child get better at talking on the phone without talking on the phone?
I have googled, of course. The majority of articles seem to be mainly about… when to talk on the phone (as in, appropriate situations for phone conversation), rather than how to hold a conversation. And maybe THAT’S where I need to start. With conversations.
Because part of learning the phone skill, I think, is learning how to hold a regular old in-person conversation. A conversation is a conversation, after all, no matter what medium you use to hold it. And I definitely could do some additional coaching in that regard. My husband and I try to teach Carla, in our own conversations, with each other and with her, not to interrupt, to pay attention, to ask questions and show interest in what the other person is saying, to take turns, etc. etc. But I admit that we aren’t perfect about it. It’s easy, when there are only three of you, to be a little bit lenient on the interruption front. And when we are all chatting around the dinner table, requiring Carla to look us in the eyes just isn’t super important. Plus, my husband and I both need to be better about putting our phones down when we are talking to one another and to Carla because THAT is certainly giving Carla the wrong idea about what’s appropriate. And it’s easy enough to have a conversation with your parents, or with people you see all the time. It’s a whole other thing to have a conversation with a stranger, or someone you see infrequently. When I am on top of things, I can remind Carla to smile when she says hello, to look the person in the eyes, to do that little “hi how are you fine how are you” exchange that humans do. But I’m not sure if you’ve noticed, most conversations are sort of impromptu, rendering preparation impossible.
Another part of learning how to talk on the phone is, I think, understanding how different it is from in-person conversation. There are no visual cues. You have to convey everything with your words.
And part of it is… a lot of intangible stuff about social cues and social expectations that Carla is still learning. Like… if one grandparent asks if you want to talk to the other grandparent, you say YES, even if it is not technically true. And… as I mentioned above, it is polite to ask how someone is doing, even if you don’t technically care. And… long silences are not a good sign, on a phone call. And… it is totally okay to end the call if you’ve run out of things to discuss, but you need to do it in a polite way, rather than just setting the phone down somewhere and wandering into a different room to build something with LEGOs.
Carla is six-and-a-half. I feel like… this should be something she’s working on, if not something she’s already mastered. But I have no frame of reference. Are other little kids having full conversations via phone? Are other parents working on this skill every weekend? Are we failing our child because we, ourselves, are so phone (and human) averse?
Do I need to start having Carla call one of her friends on the phone, to practice? Should I try to incorporate phone calls into our pretend play? Should I stop stressing out about this and remember that Carla is learning a TON of things right now and this probably doesn’t need to be a top priority?
Probably the latter. But it is really hard to notice gaps in your child’s knowledge and have no real idea how to fill them in.
Sort of how I feel when I remember that she is already six-and-a-half and we have only read half of the Ramona books and NONE of the Little House books and are the Winnie the Pooh years already in the rear-view, because we have yet to read that book all the way through. I get panicky, thinking of ALL THE THINGS I want her to experience and ALL THE THINGS I want her to learn (and read). And yet we only have so many hours in the day.
First of all, I am wondering if you might want to offer phone etiquette lessons to my mother in law? My mother in law is so inept at conversing (in general, but magnified on the phone) that she fails to make any sound for long stretches prompting me to say, ‘Hello, hello did I lose you?’ Sigh.
Before I got to the end, I was going to suggest that sCarla call her friends on the phone when requesting a playdate. You could let the other moms know your goal of increasing her phone usage to instill better phone manners. Then you suggested that idea yourself. I think that is a good start.
We still have a landline because my kids do not get a cell until high school and I still have junior high kids that are sometimes home alone and NEED to be able to make a call in an emergency or answer a call from me, ‘Are you ready because your ride will be there in a few minutes?’
When I was a kid our folks told us to answer the phone with this phrase: ‘Hello, who is this please?’ My kids still do that. I think Carla will get the hang of it with a few pointers. I would also act out different scenarios with her. Illustrate that grandma is on the line wondering where Carla disappeared to when she suddenly doesn’t answer the phone. Do a rold reversal think: Carla be the grandma and you be a 6 year old who isn’t paying attention or leaves the phone to go play, etc. I think Carla will grasp the importance of being attentive, etc.
*role reversal, sorry!
OMG, THIIIIIIIIIS. This, this, this, this, all day. It is a real problem for our kids! I was not proactive enough with mine. They’re better with grandparents’ calls – especially the 15yo – but still not 100% reliable. Ending the call is noticably lacking. They’re very abrupt. (Maybe it’s better, honestly, than 10 more minutes of “okay, well, I guess I’d better let you go….” but it’s uncomfortable for me.)
You bring up so many good points. I’m printing this out, I think, and making my kids read it. 😉
I think role reversal would be good. And I also think that learning the art of conversation is beneficial on many fronts. But she is also still so very young. I would wait a bit on the more comprehensive bits of etiquette. Right now, she should learn how to answer the phone (hello? May I tell her/him who is calling, please?), pay attention, and end the call (thank you/love you – depending on who it is – goodbye). When she’s a little older then you can work on taking messages, how to direct the conversation, etc. But by and large, when she’s old enough she will most likely rarely use a phone to talk. Kind of like the rest of us. 😉
My younger son is incredibly useless on the phone, and he is 14. I don’t remember how I actually got him to answer the phone normally. Both have cell phones and just text, but somehow – and this is unhelpful, I know – I got them to have the basics of “hello, no she’s not here right now, can I take a message.” But! It’s irrelevant because they literally never answer the landline. We still have a landline, god knows why, no one uses it. But if anyone calls, they just…let it go to the machine. Yes, we have a machine. Then THEN THEN they get annoyed by the machine’s beeping, listen to the message, and delete it. Then they don’t tell me. Long story short, I only give people my cell now. Usually it’s just my mom or mother-in-law calling anyway. The good news is that my older son carries on very long conversations over facetime with his buddies and girlfriend (ex girlfriend now) and so he has at least figured out conversation skills. BUT HE’S ALMOST 16. Well, this is singularly unhelpful, sorry.