Dinner Guests, Hosting Double Standards, and Preparation Anxiety

We have a security system in our house and two of the sensors have low batteries. Which I know because the keypad at which we control the alarm beeps to alert me of the danger. And living with low batteries is really dangerous, according to the keypad, because even though I key in a code that should let it know, “I hear you, I get it, I will call the security company right away,” it feels the need to remind me every two hours on the button. Irritating during the day, but MUCH WORSE in the middle of the night.

And of course the security company can’t send someone out right away. I mean, I GET IT. It’s just low batteries! But they can’t come until THURSDAY and that means THREE NIGHTS of getting up every two hours to key in my code and reassure the system that I AM AWARE OF THE BATTERY SITUATION AND MY IMMINENT DEMISE.

The keypad is in our bedroom. Of course, it does not bother my husband one little bit; he doesn’t even stir when it beeps.

Anyway, I am here to update you on one of my goals/aspirations for the New Year. I have ALREADY had friends over for dinner!

This is a big deal to me. You see, I like having people over to our house. I mean, in theory. I enjoy cooking, I enjoy being friendly. But man, in practiceI find it SUPER difficult.

First, even though I KNOW that it really doesn’t matter, I get all panicky about the state of my house. Is it clean enough? Is it tidy enough? Does our house smell funny? These worries send me into a cleaning frenzy prior to having someone over, which stresses me out. And I start thinking about all the projects that I want to complete – what about our horrible, mostly-destroyed ottoman? and our not-painted baseboards? and the missing kick panels on our kitchen cabinets? – and wondering if I should try to paint the fireplace before people come over and it’s ridiculous and makes me feel out of breath and frazzled.

And then there’s the food. I dither over the meal plan for weeks. (In this most recent case, we only invited people over a few days in advance, so I didn’t have to dither long.) Have I considered all their food restrictions/likes/dislikes? Have I come up with a balanced meal? No one ever seems to EAT salad if I make one, but does it need to be there to give the impression that I care about vegetables? Am I making enoughfood? (This is probably one of my biggest concerns.) Do I have a good variety of drink options?

It’s all ridiculous. When I go to someone else’s house for dinner, all I think about is whether there will be a tomato-free option. I don’t care whether they have Diet Coke or gin or a freaking salad. But for some reason, I am incapable of applying the same standards to myself. I am incapable of seeing my guests (whom I probably like! and likely think are good, easy-going, non-judgmental people!) as people who are more interested in hanging out with me and my husband than in eating a gourmet meal in an immaculate, newly-updated home.

I KNOW it is ridiculous.

And yet.

So we had this family over to dinner. We have wanted to invite them over for a long time; they’ve had us over twice, once for a playdate, once for a meal slash playdate, and it’s high time we reciprocated. And this past weekend, we were all free. I dithered only slightly over even inviting them, but I pressed forward.

I decided I would make chili, which is an easy, make-ahead type of meal (I don’t like having to cook while guests are here; it detracts from the socializing, plus people [nicely! thoughtfully!] want to help and I do not like that). But then almost immediately, I decided to make twokinds of chili – a spicy ground beef chili with a tomato base and a mild white chicken chili– both for sake of variety and in case our guests had differing spice tolerances and meat preferences. I cajoled my husband into making chocolate chip cookies. And then, to make life even more difficult on myself, I made guacamole and salsa, so we could have them (with chips) as appetizers. Before our guests arrives, I prepared a bunch of toppings for the chili (diced onions, diced tomatoes, cilantro, sour cream, shredded cheese, sliced jalapeno). The white chili was a crockpot option, so I started that early in the day. And the red chili tastes better the longer it cooks, so I started that a couple of hours before our guests arrived.

One of my biggest detractions from having people over is that my husband does not share my same level of preparation anxiety. You might think this would be a good thing, but so far in our marriage, it is not. This is not only because he does not understand how I feel in the days/hours leading up to having people over. It is because we clash on executing the actual preparations, and I end up doing (or at least feeling like I am doing) the bulk of the prep. And that makes me feel overwhelmed, overworked, misunderstood, frazzled, stressed, and put-upon. And frustrated and grouchy with my husband. Which is not really the mindset you want to have a fun, effervescent evening with friends.

I feel like I am being unfair, here, because my husband does not get a say on this blog. He cannot represent for you his own feelings, or catalog for you all the things he does to prepare. So please understand that you are getting a one-sided view of things.

On this particular day, I made a list of the things we needed to do before our guests arrived at four. We’d gone out the night before, and ended up sleeping in until NINE. Which put me immediately into a panic. My husband started out by saying that we had PLENTY of time, and so I tried to adopt that mindset and chill out a little. I gave him two projects: making the cookies (he’d made the dough the day before, so he just needed to bake the cookies) and making the white chili. And he had to get himself showered/dressed. He also wanted, separately, to go to a store and get something; I forget what, but it was on sale or something and he had to get it that day.

I unloaded the dishwasher while he made himself coffee. I made Carla’s breakfast while he made himself breakfast. I tidied up the kitchen table, which had become cluttered with Stuff. I asked him if he wanted me to dice the vegetables for the white chili and he said yes. I did that. I rinsed Carla’s breakfast dishes and put them in the dishwasher. I looked at the clock. The chili was supposed to be cooking for 6 hours, and we were nearing 11:00, so I just made the white chili myself. My husband went upstairs to do… I don’t know. Probably something very important and useful, like paying bills. (This sounds snarky but it is not meant to be; I am honestly trying very hard to give him the benefit of the doubt.)I got Carla dressed. I had made the guacamole and salsa the previous day, so I started dicing and chopping the toppings for the chili while my husband made lunch. I made lunch for Carla and coaxed her into eating it. I cleaned up lunch. I went and took a shower. I came downstairs and noted that I was supposed to make a roux for the white chili, to thicken it. My husband said it wasn’t necessary. I looked at the clock and told my husband he needed to get going. (He and I have VERY different understandings of time.) He went and took a shower. I made the red chili. He left for his errand, which I extended because I wanted him to grab me some flowers for the dinner table. It was an hour and a half until four, when our guests were to arrive. I encouraged Carla to move her toys from the living room to her bedroom. I chopped more things. I realized that we didn’t have enough spoons for dinner, so I ran the dishwasher through a quick cycle. I dried my hair and put on makeup. I cleaned up the kitchen. I ran a load of dish towels. The white chili was very watery. My husband was still gone, so I texted him asking if I should do the roux. Carla was running around asking, every five minutes, when her friend would arrive. I worried about drinks; I didn’t know if this couple drinks alcohol, so I had brought home a six-pack of unobjectionable beer and I had a bottle of wine in the fridge just in case. I worried about the kids – Carla won’t eat chili, but my friend said her kids eat anything… but what if they don’t? I washed some berries and some cherry tomatoes. I texted my husband to also grab some La Croix and a box of macaroni and cheese at the store. I unloaded the dishwasher. My husband texted me pictures of flowers and I picked a bouquet for him to bring home. I put out the salsa, chips, and guacamole. I cleaned out the sink. I fretted over whether I needed to cut some vegetables to put out with the chips. I decided against it. My husband got home with about fifteen minutes to spare. I asked him to choose some music for people to listen to. He said he wanted to put the football game on. I asked him to put music on the Amazon Echo while the game was on mute. I cut and arranged the flowers. I asked about the roux again. My husband looked at the chili and agreed it was watery. He started the roux. I cleaned off the counter. This is the most boring catalog of menial tasks ever. I realized I had failed to brush my teeth at all that day, so I ran upstairs to brush them. Carla shrieked that her friend was here. I snapped at my husband to put some music on like I’d already asked him to. He whisked the roux while Carla and I opened the door and invited our friends in.

I felt like I was busy every single second. (Is this a NORMAL level of busy? Are other people this busy in the day leading up to their dinner for guests?) (I don’t think so. Sometimes we go to dinner at the house of friends who were out at the zoo all day or had a birthday party just prior to having us over or who just said goodbye to week-long houseguests the night before. I COULD NEVER DO THOSE THINGS. I need to have plenty of space between guests, first of all. And then I also need the WHOLE DAY to complete my anxious preparations.)

These most recent dinner guests are newish friends, so we don’t know them super well. So while I was chatting with them and munching on chips, I was worrying about whether they’d like the food, and whether it was weird that I’d planned for us to all sit down at the table together. And I was fretting about timing – I’d planned for the kids to play for an hour or two, and then we’d sit down to eat; but was that making them wait too long? How long would they want to stay? Should we set up Guitar Hero for them to play? Should I try to herd everyone into the living room?

Carla was at Excitement Level 8 Billion, which translated into lots of running and shrieking and leaping off furniture. So I was also fretting about whether I was being too restrictive of the kids or not restrictive enough. Was it okay that we kind of shuttled the kids into the basement and all the grown ups stayed upstairs? Would they have preferred if we interacted with the kids more?

They left fairly early (seven thirty?), which of course made me worry that they weren’t having fun. But… it also seems like a reasonable amount of time for people to stay? I don’t know.

And the wife helped me clean everything up which makes me very uncomfortable. But she was very swift and practiced at it, so I didn’t even really have a chance to protest.

I think the dinner went okay? We had plenty to talk about, people ate the food, the kids had a raucous time which I think likely translates into fun. But man.

I really need to find some way to make it less stressful.

Some people think the way to make it less stressful is to not stress about it  but that is really terrible advice coming, I suspect, from people like my husband who are naturally low-stress people. I cannot help it. My mind begins whirring and if I don’t address the whirring it grows louder until it drowns out all other functions.

Some people might think I should just do it more often. But the anxiety around hosting happens even with people who come over ALL THE TIME – like my parents and in-laws, who come over several times a year between them, and with family friends that we have over for dinner four or five times a year or so (we swap houses every couple of months, so they are hosting us just as often). I am telling you, IT DOES NOT GET EASIER WITH PRACTICE. (The only thing that gets easier is that I worry less about the state of my home with frequent guests, because they have already seen it.)

The techniques I’ve tried, with, as you see, little success are:

  • Make things as simple as possible. (I need to work on keepingthem as simple as possible.)
  • Do as many things in advance as possible.
  • Enlist family members to help – and assign them specific tasks. (Possibly I need to also assign specific times, too.)
  • Try to only address things that are reasonable to address (i.e. NOT painting my fireplace).
  • Remind myself over and over that as a guest at other people’s homes, I don’t care about half the things I worry about people caring about.

We met a new couple a few weeks ago and I promptly asked the wife for her number so I could ask them to dinner and then actually followed up. They are coming for dinner in a few weeks. Which gives me AMPLE TIME to stress…. Or to come up with some real techniques for NOT stressing.

What do you do, to ensure that you are low-stress when you have guests over? What are your techniques for keeping things simple and fun? Should I just never invite people over again? That last one seems good, except for the dinner that’s already on the books. And I might as well TRY to overcome this Preparation Anxiety, because I inevitably start wishing I could throw a dinner party or something. WHY DOES MY BRAIN HAVE TO BE THE WAY THAT IT IS?

12 thoughts on “Dinner Guests, Hosting Double Standards, and Preparation Anxiety”

  1. There is no way your husband could tell his side of the story that would make you not right. There is no way. This is not a story of someone who does less unnecessary work because he’s less foolishly fretful; this is a story of someone who agrees to do certain work and then fails to do it or even to ARRANGE to do it—so that it’s clear that if you were NOT as fretful as you are, there WOULD BE NO DINNER, or there would be dinner near midnight and it would be missing crucial ingredients.

    I think what I would do is still entertain, since you want to, but with something that causes less work/stress. If there is such a thing. Like, I’d suggest having people over for a game night and just provide chips/popcorn in big bowls, but I personally would hate choosing/playing games, and maybe someone else would be okay with the games but would end up making two days’ worth of fiddly little homemade games snacks or something, so it wouldn’t be any less work/stress. What about a wine-and-appetizers thing where you invite an assortment of women/people and tell them to each bring a bottle of wine and something to share? That’s been very successful with my friend group (we didn’t start out as all friends). It was a little stressful at first, wondering what kind of appetizer would be liked/needed/etc. and whether it would seen as being enough effort or whatever, but now we are at the level of comfort where people feel free to pick up something from the grocery store bakery on the way over. One time my appetizer was a frozen pizza, which I cooked and then cut into very very thin slices.

  2. I have, as it turns out, another idea. What I do to reduce dinner stress if we have people over (which is virtually never) is to make something I make for dinner every single week without fail. Which means tacos. And I just make more of it than usual. I figure most people like tacos, and tacos are easy to customize. And I stress much less if I’m making a meal I’ve made a million times.

    What my parents do now when they have a group over for dinner is order pizza. Everyone always loves it and it’s much, much lower stress. Before the pizza era, they used to make a big pot of spaghetti and do a loaf or two of garlic bread.

    • YES TACOS. This is often a go-to for me, when having friends over. AND I would have made tacos for these friends had I not happened to run into them at the grocery store a few days before we decided even to invite them over and they mentioned they were making tacos. But YES. PERFECT DINNER FOOD. This cheers me endlessly, that you have reminded me of this.

  3. I agree with all that Swistle has to say above, ALL OF IT. The amount of work *I* do versus the amount of work my husband does when we have guests over? Even when he is barbequeing or smoking some kind of meat, I do every other thing, and it feels vastly unfair. But. Anyway. That’s neither here nor there. We have people over for dinner every couple of months, and I make as much as I can in advance, like you. I also make sure there’s lots of booze. Does that sound bad? I find everyone relaxes way more with a few drinks (obviously making sure there are non-alcoholic options for the driver/ non-drinkers). I make a dessert usually the day before, if I can, just to get one thing out of the way. Oh! And I never ever try making anything NEW if we are having guests over.

  4. I can kind of relate – in the “is my house & dessert perfect” department and not so much in the food department. Here is what I’ve learned over the years…eventually your husband will realize what he needs to do to keep your hysteria to a minimum (at least mine did) and to relax (yes, I know, not helpful) but here’s the thing…your guests want to enjoy your company; they aren’t there to admire the fireplace that you recently painted. Keep the menu simple (something The Husband has yet to grasp), keep a running lists of tasks that need to be completed before D-Day (and make sure it is available for all of the household to see and work on), take a deep breath and welcome them in. If they are at all snooty or judgmental because your fireplace isn’t painted make a mental note that these aren’t people you want in your life and move on.

    Now…remind me of all this as we are hosting people next next weekend…

  5. Oh, I can so relate. Coach doesn’t care if the end tables have been dusted. The kids care about nothing and they know to run and hide as I start to assign tasks. They like to mock me when I raise my voice because we are having people over, and I like to remind them that they are the reason (most of the time) that there is a mess to clean up.

    I have done a later get-together (works with parents of older kids who still need to get to their ‘stuff’) and then it is just appetizers and drinks. Although we just did this a few weeks ago, and the husband forgot to eat dinner and asked me if there was dinner – then he was embarrassed that he forgot it was appetizers. We are good friends, so I just insisted on making him a sandwich.

    As far as the kids go, YES to the basement. I don’t think parents care to see their kids interact. They are there to be social with you. \

    Coach and I have gotten into a groove. He knows I start to lose it when stuff hasn’t been done and time is slipping away and he starts to pitch in more. His biggest pet peeve is that I run upstairs to get dressed and fix my hair just as people are pulling in the driveway. He wants me downstairs and dressed when guests arrive.

    Um, did you ever read about how I fell off a chair for Mini’s grad party in June? Because I was rushing around and trying to dust the light fixtures off above the island. It was painful fall because I landed on the back of the chair right between my legs. Now I was not only upstairs showering – but I was icing my crotch. Good times!

  6. I completely relate to this post. Completely. Unfortunately I don’t really have advice. We recently hosted almost 20-ish (plus kids) for a belated Xmas thing and the only way I could handle it was to outsource. I ordered a huge amount of BBQ and sides so I only had to deal with appetizers/snacks. I even ordered desserts even though I love making desserts, but I knew I would go overboard and drive myself even more crazy, so I reigned it in. It’s the drinks that kill me. So many options to have at the ready! Alcoholic (beer, wine (red and white!)), non-alcoholic, diet, non-diet, juice boxes and milk for the kids, water (fizzy and flat)). It feels unnecessary but I had one guest who was visibly letdown because I had Coke Zero and not Diet Coke.

    My husband also gets stressed about hosting, however, his stress only kicks in AN HOUR BEFORE THE OCCASION when it is not at all helpful. It basically just results in me doing a lot of last minute reassuring.

  7. Amen, amen and amen, and I will describe the party I threw Saturday night for DH’s 50th in exactly these same ways. I was full of nervous energy all day, and had specific tasks that had to be done at specific times in order to achieve it all, and fretted over the amount of food and and and.

    Still, I want to do it more often somehow. 😉

    (We had fun, btw.)

  8. The things that helped me most were 1. having a LIST, 2. sending DH and one kid (and all grandparents, who were staying with us) OUT for most of the morning, to a kid’s bball game, and 3. outsourcing (deli tray, cake and buffalo wings all pre-made).

  9. I feel like I could have written this post haha. It’s funny though, my husband is the one who wants to like, deep clean the f*ck out of the house and I’m like, chill out – WE LIVE HERE and people have to understand that (and we both work full time). So we make sure the counters/bathrooms are clean, and that’s it. Otherwise, I’d be on the floor scrubbing grout with a toothbrush. As for food I just try to make sure it’s not too out there, and I ask ahead of time about any dietary things. Would suck to make chicken for a vegetarian!

Leave a Reply