I mentioned my mom’s potato salad recently, and I was delighted that some of you were curious about the recipe.
When I went to my parents’ new home for July Fourth, my mother sent me home with a) a HUGE hunk of ham, b) cookies, and c) – MOST IMPORTANT – a big container of potato salad.

I managed to make the potato salad last for three additional days, by eating it only for breakfast (except for one day, when I also ate it for lunch) (and then there were a few sneaky spoonsful at odd intervals). Drawing it out for so long required MUCH restraint.

When I found the recipe – in my mother’s own handwriting, so: extra precious – I learned with shock that there is MAYONNAISE in this recipe!!!! I do not care for mayonnaise, and this is certainly not a “mayonnaisey” potato salad. It is a mustardy potato salad. But… apparently there is some mayonnaise in it as well.

Note that my mother references the hard boiled eggs (which I abhor) and appeals to my potato salad sensibilities to override my dislike and add them anyway. I have never tried the salad without the hard boiled egg, so I can’t say for sure it’s truly that important. But I will say that, when very finely chopped, the egg sort of disappears into the background.
This recipe is highly flexible. I don’t recall ever having green pepper in it (though that would be a delicious addition). Sometimes there are pimientos, sometimes not. Sometimes there is celery, sometimes not. The key is in the FLAVOR, not so much the ingredients.
One highly critical element of this recipe is the dried mustard. It gives a special zing to the potato salad that you can’t get with jarred mustard alone.
BUT: The magic of this recipe is in the pickles, I think. Or, in the secret ingredient, which is pickle juice (NEVER vinegar, even though the recipe supposedly calls for vinegar), drizzled out in small amounts until the salad tastes as it should. (NOTE: This is not a pickly salad. But the pickles are CRUCIAL.)
Salt is also extremely important, and this recipe may require some salt tinkering. I think different potatoes have different levels of starchiness (even among the Idaho varietal of potato, which is called for in this recipe because of its crumbly texture), and so the salt gets absorbed differently with each batch.
Do make sure that you do MULTIPLE taste tests, to ensure proper salt/pickle level.

Delicious as a side, but also for breakfast.
