The Perils of Small Talk

Two weeks of small talk, Internet. That is what’s been going on around here.

Firstly, I joined a women’s service organization. It meets approximately eight million times a month.

Secondish, I went to a wedding where I knew about 5 people. Of the 260 who attended the wedding.

Thirdness, I went to a three-day business conference for networking and fact-finding.

Internet, I am an introvert, through and through. A couple of hours spent meeting new people is enough to make me take to my bed for a week of rest and recuperation and introspection about what an idiot I made of myself and self pity about how no one will ever want to be my friend despite my efforts and consternation about how I nevereverever know how to dress appropriately. (That last one is a lie. If the activity is lying on the couch watching Suits, I can totally dress appropriately. Well, if it’s just me. If you’re there, I will undoubtedly look like an idiot.)

Some people get their energy from being around others; I just don’t. It stresses me out and exhausts me. But I have realized that I need more human interaction. (Aside from the human interaction I’m forced into via work and wedding obligations.) I mean, I see my husband a few hours a day. And, while they make me laugh, Barney and Robin and Lily and Marshall and Ted just aren’t willing to listen to MY problems.  It’s a two-way street, guys.

So I’m trying to put myself out there. And that doesn’t mean just showing up: It means actually putting myself out there – walking up to strangers and smiling and saying hello.

SO STRESSFUL.

But that horrible diving-board moment of plunging into conversation with a stranger is not the worst thing about Putting Myself Out There. Oh no. There are Other Things.

For instance…

The handshake. Internet, no lie: 98% of the population does not know how to shake hands. I have shaken about a thousand hands (hyperbole) in the past two weeks so I feel confident in this assertion. Women, particularly, seem to SUCK at it.

There is the Used Hankie version, in which the Shakee grips the Shaker’s hand much in the way she would grip a hankie that had just received the brunt of a big ol’ Early Fall Cold Blow. Listen, Used Hankie Shakers. I know it’s not fun to smush your sweaty palm into a stranger’s. I’d be lying if I said I didn’t feel the need to snap my fingers at Sharona for a wipe after meeting someone new. BUT YOU DO IT ANYWAY, and you do it with gusto. Firmness. Strength.

But not too much strength.

That brings me to the I Will Crush You version, in which the Shakee tries to communicate her awesomeness by pulverizing the Shaker’s phalanges. Yes, ladies, my father ALSO gave me many lectures about The Art of the Firm Handshake. But that does not mean that you need to cause physical pain. It does not leave me with the impression of “My, that girl knows how to shake hands! I suspect she will be smart and capable in all things!” No. It leaves me with the impression of pain to which I will respond with a Pavlovian sort of cringe in every future encounter.

Summary: If you are headed into a handshake with the thought, “I am going to leave an impression on you all right. The impression of my giant diamond ring in the flesh of your palm.” you are doing it wrong.

Side Note: Being on the receiving end of so many Horrible Handshakes has left me shaken (ha! dual meaning!) about my own Handshake Aptitude.  And I don’t know if you know this, but it’s almost impossible to shake your own hand in any way approximating reality. Perhaps I need to enlist my husband’s help to make sure I’m neither a Used Hankie nor an I Will Crush You sort of handshaker.

Then there’s the issue of…

Appropriate footwear. Events that primarily revolve around meeting people and/or chitchatting require long periods of standing. Internet, I’ll be straight with you: I’m a sitter.  I don’t wear shoes except to take out the trash and get the mail. And let’s be honest: I make my husband do those things most times.

This is all to say: shoes hurt my feet. Flip flops, sneakers, pumps, wedges, boots, EVEN UGGS. They all hurt my feet if I wear them long enough simply because I have the feet of some sort of coddled Elizabethan princess who gets transported from place to place on a satin litter. So choosing footwear is kind of like picking a night in the stocks vs. a public flogging: painful and humiliating no matter what.

But I have double footwear angst when embarking on a night of Meet-and-Greetery. Because not only do I need something that won’t turn my feet into hamburger meat, I need something cute.

I HAVE NEVER MET A CUTE SHOE THAT WAS COMFORTABLE.

(Confidential to E: I do not have your long legs so please do not suggest I try to pull off a pair of those cute flats you [used to] have a thousand pairs of. FLATS ARE NOT MY FRIEND.)

Listen, if you are about to say something reasonable and sensible like, “Wear something comfortable even if it’s a potato,” stop. First of all, a potato? Really? That doesn’t SOUND comfortable.

Second of all, no. Shoes are major ego-boosters. They make me taller. They make me feel cuter. They make an outfit.  And I know you should want people to Like You for Who You Are. But I sense the up-downs and the critical stares.

I want to look Pulled Together and Stylish when I meet people for the first time. Instead of what I normally look like, which is Chili-Stained Pajama Lady. Because then my weak-tea personality doesn’t have to do the double work of compensating for Crazy-Wear. I prefer my clothes to act as a time-release capsule, wherein strangers meet me thinking that I’m at least exteriorally normal, and then I can expel little bursts of Real Me over time, so as not to send a heart-attack-inducing amount of Real Me coursing straight to the brain. See? This is all for others’ safety.

Anyway, I spend way too much time contemplating footwear before these events. I may even order brand new shoes from Zappos just so I have something to wear to meet strangers. I know. IT IS A SICKNESS. (Thank goodness for free returns, amiright?)

P.S. No matter what I choose, I always end up feeling dowdy. SIGH.

But choosing footwear pales in comparison to…

Entering and leaving a conversation. Oh Internet. You can reach so many levels of awkwardness at an event filled with strangers.

One of those awkward levels is trying to insert yourself into a group of people. Which is sometimes the only option besides hanging out by the buffet table and trying to look really interested in the rye crackers.  Believe me – there is only so much cracker examination you can do before you look like a crazy person.

But it’s so incredibly awkward to walk up to a group of people and join the conversation. Some groups will naturally open up to bring you in. Others will not. But no matter what, you always have a decision: Laugh along heartily with whatever the speaker just said as though you’d been there the whole time or hang awkwardly at the edges, waiting for a lull or a kindly person to draw you in with a question.

It can be equally awkward to leave a group. Saying brightly, “I need a refill!” seems like a good plan. Unless you still have half a drink left. But easing out of the group without a word is simultaneously creepy, insulting to the others, and depressing.

Who am I kidding? I am totally standing over the buffet table, feigning intense fascination with the veggie dip.

And, of course, the silent-but-deadly aspect of meeting people…

Repeating the same boring shit over and over and over and over and over and zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. I get that small talk has a valuable purpose in life.  But there is only so much “Where are you from? Where’d you go to college? What do you do?” that a girl can take. Seriously.

But I do appreciate the women who are Rapid Fire Question Askers. These women have no qualms about being nosy. (Handy Recognition Tip: These are typically the same women who give you the bone-shattering handshakes. So, you win some, you lose some.)They simply want to get All the Information in the shortest time possible. So they are straightforward and brisk and if you don’t watch yourself, you’ll end up telling them your deepest secrets, your mother’s maiden name, what you ate for lunch last Tuesday, and your bra size. But I like a person who gets down to business.

What I do look forward to is a time when these women are more than strangers. When we can talk about Subjects of Depth. When we can joke with each other. When we can hang out easily, without worrying about subject matter or exit strategies or footwear.

Oh Internet. Why is meeting people as an adult such a horrible, frustrating, embarrassing, exhausting, awkward, heart-pounding enterprise?

And who am I kidding? I’ll always worry about footwear.

26 thoughts on “The Perils of Small Talk”

  1. Entering and leaving conversations is SO. HARD. This is exactly what I hate about phones–it makes it sooo much more pronounces when you’re doing that. Ugh!!!

    I agree–it’s sooo much better when you know someone and can worry less about the other things and talk about Subjects of Depth. If only it weren’t so hard to get there in the first place.

  2. I share your trepidation not your fascination altho that could be attributed to size 12 Flat Feet and size Zero fashion sense coupled with little to no desire to learn. What we end up with is leggings topped by a sarong tied around my hips just below my waistline. In jacket land where I live, I get to color coordinate with my outer wear more often than the blouse or jumper I have on.

    Yeah, that’s what my daughter says too. Oh well, I like it and it certainly is radiant in the dominant monocolor clothing here-shades of black over grey.

  3. Entering and leaving the conversation can be really difficult. Which is why you’ll find me gulping down a drink when entrenched in a boring/bad conversation, just so I’ll have an excuse to duck out. Yikes. As far as footwear, I only wear flats. I’d rather look short and dumpy than risk inevitably falling over or tripping and spilling things.

  4. Let me introduce you to my cute shoes: http://www.zappos.com/softwalk-jupiter-black-soft-kid I learned about them on the internet, where I get all my good information, and they are super comfortable. I think that is the most I have ever spent on a pair of shoes and it was so worth it. Plus, I’ve had them for two years now and they still look brand new.

    I hate small talk. Hate it. And I am not good at it. That is why I like my internet friendships. By the time we meet in person, we’ve already known each other for years.

  5. Are we the same person? Small talk bores me to tears and zaps all my energy. Networking = rush for adults. Though I hated it (rush in college), I did sort of master small talk.

    As for footwear the only shoes I find comfortable are sneakers. Anything else = lack of comfort. Just deal. that’s what I do.

    And my goodness I suck at entering/ leaving a conversation. it’s awkward x 1 million and I feel so uncomfortable.

    Just thinking about all this makes me feel for you. Drink some tea, lay on the couch, read a book and don’t talk to anyone. That’s what I do when I’m ‘talked’ out.

  6. I HATE small talk. Sometimes I even find it hard to initiate/maintain small talk with peopele I’m friends with! Most of the time I just want to be quiet and listen, y’know?

  7. Inserts, my friend. Join the geriatrics (me) and get some Dr. Scholls inserts to put in your shoes. You will wonder where they’ve been all your life. I put them in every single pair I own (except flip flops, natch). I even found ballet flats horridly uncomfortable until I became friends with the Doc.

  8. Dear Lord, I hate the rapid fire question askers. They make me feel like I’m being interrogated.

    I have a comfortable high heeled shoe suggestion for you, not that you asked for one. I have some 2″ Cole Haan Air shoes (not the exact name) that I got on sale. They are really comfy for heels because they have the Nike Air insoles.

  9. I know this is probably going to sound SUPER awkward, but I somehow look forward to handshakes. My grandpa always made sure I had a firm-but-not-too-firm handshake and I’m pretty proud of it 😉 HA! So I’m always interested when meeting someone how/if they will want to shake hands.
    Ok, now that I’ve made myself sound like a complete and utter weirdo…
    small talk – oh how I HATE it! It’s so difficult to get out of, I agree!

  10. Ugh, just reading this made me feel twitchy. I hate meeting people, I hate talking to people, I could happily stay in my house for months without ever speaking to another person. If I end up in Hell in the afterlife, it will be a faculty party where I don’t know anyone.

    As for shoes, I am the same way, but I can’t even suffer the pain of pretty shoes. I just wear the dumpy ones that don’t hurt for a while, although even the dumpy ones hurt after a few hours. It makes me sad that there are no attractive shoes for women with plump feet. If I ever win the lottery I am starting a company to make pretty shoes for women who have wide, plump feet. Like Jimmy Choos but twice as wide. And I will make them in a reasonable price point. (I will also have another company that makes clothing for the forgotten women of the size 10 to 16 contingent. I am full of ideas.)

    The bad part is I KNOW the shoes are dumpy, and that they make me look dumpy, which does not make me think “I am an attractive, confident woman, now go talk to someone!”

    So, you have my sympathy.

  11. “Some people get their energy from being around others; I just don’t.” I totally feel you on this. I’m the same way, and trying to get my friends/acquaintances to understand this (without sighing exasperatedly and saying, “I NEED my effing SPACE, yo! I just can’t TALK to you right now.”) is like pulling teeth. My middle name might as well be “antisocial.” But really, I recharge by being alone, not by being in the midst of a group where I have to think about what I’m doing and what I’m saying and if I have something in my teeth and if my hair is sticking up. That just doesn’t charge me up at all.

  12. Small talk is the worse. It would be easier for the person to say “i am asking you these random questions because I would like to know where you rank on the social ladder”.

    I have mastered leaving the conversation. I usually say that I am returning to the snack table to pick up some extra napkins and ask if anyone else in the group needs one. Usually everyone says no and keeps gabbing, and I make my escape. Not only did I excuse myself politely, but I also appeared to care about the other ppl in the group. LOL! I have witnessed two people use this technique before I could, so I had to use the back up line ” I am going to run to the bathroom before the meeting starts…”

  13. Shoes that are cute & stylish: tsubo and indigo by clarks. Not all of them are, but a fair number.

    Also? Next time you have a firm handshaker, pull your hand away, lick your palm and say, “Do over.” 😛

  14. I can’t back this up with personal experience, but a small story for you:

    This woman I know wears the same cute heels every time I see her. Three hours of church? No problem! 4 hours volunteering at the consignment sale? Bring it on. Seriously, she wears them often and for long periods of time. I once commented “Don’t you feet hurt?” (I was wearing mold-to-your-feet Birkenstock and my feet were just starting to hurt) and she said “Nope, these are hush puppies.”

    So, for you viewing pleasure:

    http://www.hushpuppies.com/US/en/Womens-Dress

    They are expensive, but apparently super comfortable!

  15. Oh my gosh are you sure you and I weren’t separated at birth with like a 20 year gap?

    I can relate to every.single.thing. you said. From the shoes, to the boring conversations to the entering and exiting conversations.

    Part of my problem is I have to meet people and talk all day long as part of my job — they don’t allow me as the leader of an org to hide in the back where I’d like to hide:)

    So I feel you!

    Small talk has its place but oh mah gawd sometimes it just too too much.

  16. Kathy Lee and Hoda just had a segment about handshakes. It was interesting.
    Also my past two handshakes with guys, have been the limpy used hankie shakes. One of them being a doctor. I would have thought his handshake would have been more firm. Im on the bigger side and 6’2″ so they would have to squeeze pretty hard for it to even hurt. I was just like seriously? Your a guy and a doctor you shake my hand like one. LOL

  17. I recently realized that I suck at leaving conversations. I blame an old boss who used to barge into my cube a million times a day and annoy me. After a while, the only way to get him to leave was to just stop talking and turn back to my computer. Imagine my horror when I realized one day (TWO YEARS after that guy wasn’t my boss anymore) that I still do this. I brought Lucy into work to show her off to work people and I totally strolled away without ENDING the conversation at least three times. It’s like I’m saying “okay, I’m done with you nove. Moving along.” So awkward.

  18. I so agree with you on this. I hate going to receptions or other networking events if I don’t already know most of the people who will be there. Entering/exiting conversations is the WORST. I hate how awkward and forced it always feels.

    I feel like there are two types of women at networking events: those wearing cute shoes and those who are not. If I’m in the cute shoe crowd on a particular night, I feel self-conscious that I appear too concerned with vanity and not very smart. If I’m in the comfy shoe crowd, I feel like a dowdy shrew. Sigh.

  19. I laughed out loud reading this post! So true! My husband is one of those “being around lots of people energizes me” kind of people, while I feel like I need a vacation after a business mixer. I loved your commentary on the subject!

  20. You know what? I think adult life should have at least a monthly college-social-life meet. Maybe we all move in to a dorm for a weekend each month so we can make friends. I honestly find that once you’ve left college you were supposed to have met all the friends that you will have for the rest of your life. And what if you move? i.e. I moved. To a state that no one that I know lives in. How am I supposed to make friends? Then there was the whole, once you have kids you’ll get mommy friends….but the problem is that I work for 50+ hours a week and then do my chores/pick up house/buy us food so we don’t starve. When am I going to make mommy friends that can hang out in the 5 minutes when I am not running around like a chicken with my head cut off?

    You know what the thing is though? (ps- sometimes I forget this is a public comment….guh…sorry other people) I am a freakin extravert. And I’m social. And I can small talk. And I love wearing cute shoes that I can walk/stand in for hours. And I still can’t make any friends.

    maybe it’s me?

  21. Oh god. I am in a position where networking is KEY and when I was pregnant, it was AWFUL. No cocktails to lube me up before sidling into a conversation? OH GOD.

    Also, that sentence makes me think of Bridget Jones and that scene at the book release party. At least we’re not that bad, right? Right.

  22. re: shoes
    As a physician I am ALWAYS looking for shoes that are comfortable AND cute. My favorites so far are: a pair of mary jane type naturalizers called the “referee” – adorable and great.

    #2 – earth shoes – these are kind of pricey, but they do make some cute styles. They have a heel that sits slightly lower than the toe which is also supposed to make your calves stronger and make you stand up straighter.

  23. I totally hear you. I have made exactly TWO close friends since I graduated from college. One was a co-worker and one was from a mom’s group when I has my daughter. I have met literally HUNDREDS of women in my mom’s group in the last 4 years and I can call many of them acquaintances and I even call some of them friends (using the term loosely), but I have only two (other than college friends) that I would consider calling on the phone just to say “hi”. That is how I judge how good of friends I am with someone. Would it feel weird for either party if I called and just said, “hey, what’s up?” without a specific purpose? If the answer is no, we are friends. But, I don’t know why out of SO MANY people I have met, I am not at that level with more people? It feels like most of them don’t want or need closer friends…maybe they have enough so they just want casual friendships-like someone to meet at the park with the kids once a week? Anyway, all of this rambling and I am really trying to say that, YES, it is HARD to make friends as an adult. I think the same probably goes for dating and meeting men once out of college.

Leave a Reply