Book Review: A Wolf at the Table by Augusten Burroughs

I have not read Running with Scissors. There was a huge furor about this book a couple of years ago. I believe it may have even become a movie.

But even though I never read this book, it put the author – Augusten Burroughs – on my radar.

Now, I think it’s necessary to tell you that I do NOT choose books by their covers. (My husband does that.) Instead, I choose a book by its title.

So when I saw A Wolf at the Table on a “Noteworthy Paperbacks” display at Barnes & Noble, I was intrigued. (I have a thing about wolves.)

Spoiler Alert: This book has nothing to do with wolves.

It’s a memoir – the prequel to Running with Scissors – a genre which I have recently come to enjoy. What can I say? I love the little voyeuristic thrill of peeking inside someone’s life.

I am torn about how to describe this book to you. Hence the stall tactics of the previous six paragraphs.

Mini plot summary: Augusten Burroughs gives a first-person account of his extremely dysfunctional upbringing. He grew up with a mother who was abused, psychologically fragile, and who constantly retreated to her safe little bubble of art…. A brother who was emotionally or physically absent… and a father who was at best a neglectful and disinterested parent, at worst, a psychotic alcoholic on the verge of murder.

The story was chilling. Captivating. If you can’t stand for pets to die in books, don’t read this one.

The sick relationship between Augusten’s parents was one of those things you can’t help gawking at. After physical and psychological abuse, I wondered over and over, why does this woman stay with her husband? How can she allow her two sons to live in this atmosphere? Yes, she left on occasion. But she always returned. The classic abuse cycle, right?

The things Augusten’s father did were… unthinkable.

But then again… The story is told from the point of view of a child. A child who doesn’t have all the facts. A child who doesn’t fully understand the things he sees and hears. And – while he portrays his father as someone who is always on the edge of killing – the end of the book raises the possibility that perhaps young Augusten misread or overdramatized the extent of his father’s homicidal tendencies. This is supported in part by Augusten’s mother’s failure to see or believe or react properly to the father’s misdeeds.

But then again, again… Augusten’s brother leaves home at a young age, ostensibly to get away from the unhealthy atmosphere. And he teaches Augusten how to shoot a gun, presumably to ensure that Augusten can protect himself against their father.

My big issue with this book is that it’s entirely plot-driven. The prose wasn’t horrible or anything. It was okay. But the entire meat of the book is the plot. I suppose that’s fine. I mean, I read the book pretty quickly. I was interested until the last page. But I like writing for its beauty, too. You can have both. See: anything by Jonathan Safran Foer, Audrey Niffenegger, Vladimir Nabokov, or Jhumpa Lahiri.

Also, I think Augusten takes some liberties with the plot that were unsatisfying. There’s a particular scene at Martha’s Vineyard where he pretty much invents a scene… and you don’t find out until afterward that it was a fantasy. Which seems like cheating to me. Writers – of memoirs and non fiction – should be able to make the truth sing. They shouldn’t need to bolster it with fiction or fantasy.

The other thing… I guess my hope for memoirists is that they take the bad in their lives and turn it into something. I didn’t get that sense with this book. Yes, I know that there’s another book out there, another chapter of Augusten’s life that he wrote about. So perhaps he redeems himself in that one. But in A Wolf at the Table, I never felt like Augusten was able to transcend the horrible things that happened to him. He remained broken, somehow, even after the people who murdered his childhood were dead and gone. Maybe this is an honest portrayal of life. Maybe you can’t always make something good out of the horrible. Maybe once you are broken, you stay broken.

But I guess, to me, if you write about your life, you are hoping to find that good side. You feel like you have something to share with others, something that will teach them something about life or pain or themselves. I didn’t learn anything about myself or life from this book, other than the well-known fact that life is hard for some. Atrocious, even. That unthinkable things happen in this world. That an innocent child can be irreparably damaged by others, even by the very people who are supposed to love and protect him.

I guess my disappointment here is my own fault. I am an idealist, a romantic. I want to believe that good – even if it is a tiny silver – can come out of horror and evil. The only good that came of Augusten’s horrible childhood is that his mother finally finally rescued him. But the rescue was temporary. Small. And she removed Augusten to a place that held even more horrors.

Maybe the good that we’re supposed to find is survival. That you can live in the worst conditions – unfathomable conditions, really – and still survive. This is the message of many Holocaust books, after all. But somehow, it doesn’t resonate here – not for me.

Should you read this book? It was a page turner, that’s for sure. So sure, go ahead and pick it up. But don’t expect it to make your list of Best Written Books of All Time.

Now I’m going to pick up Running with Scissors.

As always, I’d love to hear your thoughts on this book, if you’ve read it. Have at it in the comments – but beware that there may be spoilers.

6 thoughts on “Book Review: A Wolf at the Table by Augusten Burroughs”

  1. This was so interesting for me, because I have read Running With Scissors, but haven’t read Wolf at the Table yet. I think you hit on something when you talked about something being broken. I think there was very little that was redeemable in Augusten’s early life, so I think he avoids sugar coating any of it. And if Wolf is written as snarkily as Scissors is, I get the impression (from the books and interviews I’ve seen with him) is that he harbors a lot of resentment about his past, and is unlikely to make excuses for his parents.

    I think the most redeemable thing about him and his books is that he came out of it with a wicked sense of humor. I was laughing out loud as I was reading Scissors. He has a third book, called Dry, in which you may get your “take the bad in their lives and turn it into something”. He, unsurprisingly, grows up to struggle with substance abuse and Dry is about him struggling and trying to overcome that.

    I suggest reading Scissors and Dry…if only for an amazing story of pain and an attempt to overcome it. You’re right, they’re not the most beautifully written, but how do you beautify abuse? Ok, I’ll shut up now 🙂

  2. I read Running with Scissors and it was OK. A little weird for my tastes, so I think I’ll prob pass on the prequel. But I can imagine the prequel and I’m sure you will love Scissors!

  3. Wow, thanks for writing about this, I didn’t know there was a prequel to RWS. I read that book a couple of years ago, and as weird as it was, I still loved it. Totally captivating. Anyway, I definitely have a new book on my To-Read list, so thanks!

  4. Although I’ve never read either of Augusten’s books, for some reason Running With Scissors always makes me think of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nightime. That was a good book, and although it dealt with a serious subject -autism- there was something subtly uplifting about it. I have been looking for new books to read so maybe I’ll check out A Wolf at the Table. Thanks for the review!

  5. Ahhhhh Augusten.

    I’ve read Wolf, Running with Scissors, and Dry and have to admit I’ve loved them all. I think the reason I gave more freedom to his seemingly loose writing in Wolf is that I had already fallen in love with Running with Scissors years before it was a movie and sensation.

    I think it’s hard to believe this man’s life, his world is this wild, this dysfunctional, this horrible. But if you read how the events of his childhood continue into his teens, and then in Dry read how it morphed and distorted the person he tries to become as an adult, I think you’ll see why Wolf is so important in his telling of his life.

    Also, his absent brother John Elder has gone on to write about his own life in a book called Look Me In The Eye about his struggle growing up with asperger’s syndrome. This book also helps to paint another side of the family, and help to close in on this twisted story.

    http://www.amazon.com/Look-Me-Eye-Life-Aspergers/dp/0307395987

    (sigh)

    Lordy I love reading…

Leave a Reply