On the Other Hand…

Some things, when I hear them, make me irrationally angry.

I recognize that the anger is irrational. But that usually doesn’t do much to still my pounding heart or force the blood from my cheeks.

However, I do try very hard to see things from the other person’s perspective. So today I would like to explore one aspect of medicine that drives me bonkers.

It’s the bias against medical students and medical residents.

I know one woman whose son is a physician. Yet this woman is adamantly opposed to allowing medical students or medical residents treat her or any of her family members.

I’ve heard her, time and again, mention how she won’t return to a certain emergency department because it’s populated with so many residents. Or how she would never let a medical student perform a physical exam. Or how she would not let a medical resident – especially not an intern – treat her.

I’ve heard her tell others that new interns start in July, so that’s the worst time to get admitted to the hospital or be seen in an ER.

And the other day, I heard the wife of a medical resident telling another wife that “You have the right to request a medical student or resident NOT provide care to you.”

Listen, I am going to say right up front that I find this offensive. Not to me, personally, but to physicians-in-training everywhere.

And especially when it comes from a family member of a physician. How can you expect your son or spouse to become a top-notch doctor if even you – you who know just how hard he’s worked, how much education he’s had, how smart and dedicated he is – won’t give people in his position the chance to gain experience?

Now I’m taking a breath.

You see, I understand where these women are coming from. To an extent. And maybe you share their reluctance. When it’s your health – or your life – on the line, you want the absolute best care possible. It’s natural to want the most experienced physician to treat you. And it’s natural to want these things for your loved ones as well.

If there’s even a chance that your doctor is too inexperienced to spot a tricky symptom… or to make a rare diagnosis… or to know of a specialized treatment… Well, you’d want her off the case, right?

I get it. When it comes to yourself or a loved one, you need to be selfish. I totally understand that impulse to get “the best.”

But on the other hand…

How do you expect a doctor to gain experience if he’s shut out of cases when he’s an intern?

How do you expect him to hone his diagnostic skills if he’s limited to the “easy” cases?

How do you expect him to think of all the latest technologies and drugs if he’s not been exposed to them?

It is reasonable to expect the best care from an experienced physician if you refuse to help a young physician gain that experience?

On the other hand…

Why should YOU – or your child or grandmother or husband – be the person on whom a young doctor practices?

Why not reserve that dubious privilege for the poor, the uninsured, the mentally disabled? *

Or why not leave it to “someone else” to say, “Sure, even though you’re just a third year med student/medical intern, you can operate on me/treat my diabetes/sew up my face/deliver my baby.”

Yes, I see that it’s distasteful to be someone’s “test case,” to have a physician “practice” on you. It can’t be fun to be the guinea pig when a med student is first learning how to do stitches or an intern is learning how to insert a chest tube.

On the other hand…

How else will they learn? I know there are tricks. His third year of med school, my husband had a weird contraption made up of a sponge glued to a piece of wood on which he practiced sewing. I’ve heard of practicing “drawing blood” on oranges.

But nothing can stand in for a real human, with real health issues.

Sometimes I think this is a side effect of the “American way.” Many of us feel entitled to the best of everything. And we want it without putting ourselves at risk.

But I think in this case, we are not only looking out for our own self interests… we are doing it to the detriment of future classes of physicians.

So is there a way to reconcile this problem? I believe so.

Now, I’m not saying that you have to swallow your fears and allow a med student to sew up your face… or have an intern perform heart surgery on you. If you are concerned, maybe ask that an attending oversee your case, or that your intern work in tandem with an upper-level resident. But I’d encourage you to be open to allowing med students examine you (they aren’t responsible for your care – they will discuss your case thoroughly with a more experienced physician) and even stitch up your arm. (My husband was excellent at making stitches – even as a med student.)

And no matter which doctor you have, ask questions. Be informed. Bring a friend or family member with you to listen in and ask questions you might not have considered.

Share your concerns with your physician. Ask her to explain everything she’s doing and why, so you know her thought processes and her reasoning behind the treatment she gives you. And if something doesn’t seem right to you… if something doesn’t feel right… if you feel like something is being overlooked – SPEAK UP.

If you take an active role in your healthcare, I firmly believe you can get the best care AND you can help a physician-in-training gain more experience.

* I have actually heard people suggest this as an alternative to having to deal with interns themselves.

12 thoughts on “On the Other Hand…”

  1. My physicians are at a teaching hospital by choice. I always allow the resident to see me & offer their opinion. I always end the appointment with both the attending & the resident, and frankly it makes me feel better knowing that the resident made a diagnosis that their attending physician concurred with. I had my foot sewn up by a resident and it didn’t bother me one bit. How do we expect people to learn??

  2. Same thing in the legal world. Doesn’t help that I am a little younger than most new attorneys, am a female {in our smaller city, it is very much a men’s club still} and look like I am 12. It is hard because I needed someone to hire me for my first divorce. One client had to have the first will I drafted. One corporation was the unlucky one that had me practice on them preparing legal documents. It is just the way it is.

    What some people forget is that while we are still pretty “green”, we are fresh from school, still consumed by the desire to learn, and have received more innovative {and perhaps better?} training than those older than us. And we still care…we are still incredibly passionate.

  3. I agree with Daisy, I think that what these people aren’t fully considering is interns and residents operate with supervision, does that mean that every diagnosis is gone through with a fine tooth comb, probably not. But it does mean that you are being treated by a more experienced physician in the long run, and it also means that there are more Dr’s looking at your chart. I know that in my profession I have a bad day, and might miss something, it’s nice to know that my teammate who is more experienced than I am is also looking over my shoulder and is likely to catch something I miss. I would pick a resident or an intern any day over having an overworked, underpaid family practice physician who’s been in his career for 30 years, and is bitter that he can’t quite retire yet b/c he’s so far in debt for his practice…. I think a student is much more likely to think “outside the box” and also to try to get every diagnosis perfect b/c they feel like their grades and their future are riding on their performance with every patient. Whereas the overworked established Dr. is probably thinking about what he can do to earn the most amount of money for the least amount of work to just get through the day.

  4. Well, my husband is in residency at Mayo Clinic. It is world renowned and has tons of resident and its own medical school. It sounds like “someone” is a little uneducated as well as condescending. I’m sorry you have to be around that.

  5. It is a paradox.

    But this mentality ignores the fact that the practice of medicine is a team effort.

    A new nurse is just as likely to screw up your treatment which could have been prescribed by a top-notch attending.

    So as it has already been alluded to, sometimes the residents have the best of both worlds when it comes to treating patients — they have the recent knowledge and freshly practiced skill-set and the motivation to succeed, in addition to an experienced attending to answer to.

    It is this sort of ignorance that will screw up the system.

    People can be diligent about their own medical care without being arrogant about a little bit of knowledge. They can be treated by residents and get a second opinion from an attending if they so desire, but to outright refuse treatment? How entitled.

    Doctors are fleeing the profession partly because of the ignoramuses that infiltrate their practice, armed with their google-sourced medical information and sense of entitlement.

  6. That is HORRIFYING to suggest that the poor/disabled get shuttled off into what someone believes is worse care. That’s terrible! People can be the worst. I think you’re really right about the American sense of entitlement. Sad.

    My hospital/clinic is a teaching facility, so I’d say 1/3 times I go (which is a lot, ugh) I first see a resident and then the attending. For the most part, I really love the residents! They try so hard and are so conscientious about getting every detail and are very eager to do the best job they can. There’ve been several cases I’ve noticed where they were making mistakes obvious enough that even I could tell (like not knowing how to take blood pressure–which I know is usually a nurse’s task, so fair enough, I guess–or totally not listening to my chief complaint and going off on another tangent altogether about something they just learned), but that’s why it’s med SCHOOL, and that’s why the attending physician is there, to make it a learning experience. So, that’s never bothered me, and I love having appointments w/ residents, because a) they’re great and b) it’s always great to have two minds thinking about your case. And also, it’s great to know in a small small way you’re sort of helping to contribute to someone’s education.

    That said. Two years ago J had surgery, and it was supposed to be a fairly basic surgery, and because of that the attending surgeon allowed a resident to do the stitching afterward. But he ended up doing a really poor job and not stitching tightly enough, and I’ll leave out most of the details of what happened since this is a public place 🙂 but because of the error all kinds of bad swelling/side effects happened and J was in EXCRUCIATING pain and was back in the ER for 12 hours while a huge staff tried to deal with the horrific complications. He’s fine now, but it was terrifying and incredibly, incredibly painful. And obviously I know it’s not fair to make blanket statements about residents based on one guy, and I would never do that, but that experience did kind of make me a little wary about experience when surgery is involved. Sure, people have to learn somehow–and probably even to some degree mistakes are part of the learning process–but it sucks if they’re ‘learning’ on you (or your husband) and the results are that harrowing. I think the attending surgeon was totally also at fault, though–he should have done a much better job checking up. So the blame goes both ways, I guess. (And it’s tough during surgery–during an appointment you can advocate for yourself, but of course during surgery you’re out cold.)

    But yeah, I agree with you–there’s really no easy answer, and there’s a lot of ‘on the other hand’ type issues. Because people do have to learn, and that does mean that every now and then something like that’s going to happen.

    This is turning into a novel, but one of my best friends is an ICU nurse, and hearing all her stories about things that go wrong/mistakes that are made–I honestly think lots of times you’re probably better off with someone who’s still learning, because in most cases I’m sure there are a lot more checks and safeguards in place to prevent error.

    This was really thought-provoking and interesting! I’ve thought about this a lot but it’s especially interesting to hear from someone who has a more personal tie to the issue.

  7. P.S. I also have several friends who are physicians, and one is an ER attending, but apparently hasn’t had to actually stitch anyone up since 1999. (I’m not sure how he avoided that ….) He was telling us the other night about how he had to give a guy stitches in his finger and he did a terrible job because it had been so long and the guy could totally tell. So obviously it’s not just a resident/student vs. attending thing.

  8. My husband is a fourth year medical student, and he always says that residents often do the best work because they are fresh out of school and have been trained on all of the latest technology. For this reason, I would always want to be treated or deliver a baby at a teaching hospital.

  9. I definitely have an opinion on this… but I am not feeling all too eloquent with my words – so I will just give it a blunt go.

    My boyfriend is going to be an AMAZING doctor. He is starting residency next year and he is going to be thrown into the thick of things. He will be as prepared as you can be after spending months in the clinic, hundreds of ours in the OR, sitting in lectures of all sorts and checking in on various patients.

    My boyfriend will be an amazing doctor because he will be overseen by amazing attendees right? He will be generously allowed to work on patients who put their trust in the teaching he has received and in the procedure his going to apply on them.

    I can promise you that mistakes such as the one done on Kelly’s husband is NOT because that resident wasn’t capable of suturing to the best of his ability – but because that attending who should have been paying FAR better attention to what was being sutured didn’t.

    Often times I would trust the knowledge, the eagerness, the bedside manner of a student/resident than a stale, old, bitter, overworked, ready to retire attending.

    The bottom line is the doctors have to learn. Once they graduate from medical school – they are just that – doctors. They are the future of the countries medicine. They are the innovators, the leaders, the cure to future disease, the inventor of a new and advanced procedure. Some will be good, some will be GREAT.

    I agree with K – medicine is a team effort. From start to finish.

    I am sure I could add more but as you can tell S, this get my blood BOILING as well!!

  10. I can’t comment on the medical industry. I only bitch about law students 😉

    I think Daisy has a good point, it’s like a free second opinion. I think the one scenario I’d not be OK with is to have a baby/other delicate female business with a room full of interns a la Grey’s Anatomy. (Does that even happen in real life?? I think it must, because when I was in the ER for my arrhythmia last year the old doctor came in with 3-4 interns with clipboards behind him, but they didn’t talk to me I don’t think.)

    I’d hope that whoever sticks their fingers/face up there would be someone I’m comfortable with, which is why it took me years to find a gynecologist in my new hometown. I would seriously drive 3 hours to see my old gynecologist at home, I just didn’t want to have to find a new doctor that much. But I lucked out and found a fabulous new lady. She’s relatively young (35 or younger) and I had no qualms about letting her do my surgeries. So I guess all I am saying, even though it’s taken me a novel of a comment to make my point, is that I’d hope to keep the number of people performing internal exams to be kept to a minimum while I’m in labor (in a distant, far-off future). And not because of their education or greenness. Just because of privacy. You know. It’s my sacred place and it is hard to share and all that jazz.

  11. Yowza, I see both sides. Truly. I had a resident do one of my visits while pregnant. She was REALLY nervous and that didn’t help. Everyone has to learn, but it was SO PAINFUL. I know she has to learn, everyone does, but can you fault me for wanting my regular gentle doctor with upteen years of experience? Plus, I didn’t know how to act. I just smiled at her because she was so nervous. Should I have told her that she was hurting me and “doing it wrong?” I mean, what is proper etiquette? I would never NOT go in July or something ridiculous like that. Silly. And I agree with the above, I had FIVE folks in there when I delivered and it was RIDICULOUS. It is a private, painful matter and when you don’t have an epi it is downright HOLY COW. There is a happy medium, but I don’t know what it is.

Leave a Reply