A Spicy Question

I’m having some salt and pepper issues, Internet. You’d think these common spices wouldn’t be so troublesome, but they are, for me at least.

And I need your help.

Situation #1:

Let’s say you go to someone’s house for dinner.

Perhaps your host serves you some delightful chicken dish and maybe a baked potato on the side.

You like baked potatoes. But you don’t like them plain. Maybe you prefer them with some butter and a little sprinkling of salt and pepper.

Butter – check.

Salt and pepper – MIA.

This is an etiquette issue that sort of eludes me. Do you ask for salt and pepper? Do you tough it out with just butter?

That’s my fall-back, by the way. To just deal with the potato. Or whatever else I would normally pepper. (And I luuuurrrrve pepper. It makes everything better, IMHO.)

But Situation #1 is admittedly the least of my concerns. The salt and pepper issue gets a little trickier with…

Situation #2:

Let’s say you go to someone’s house for dinner.

On the dinner table are salt and pepper. (There to be USED, right?)

Your host serves you a beautiful dish of whatever. A dish that they have, presumably, seasoned to perfection. Unlike the potato, which did not come pre-seasoned.

“Mmmm. Smells good!”

But on tasting it, well, it’s delish… But maybe could use a little salt? (If I’ve learned anything from watching Top Chef, SALT LEVELS ARE TOTALLY SUBJECTIVE, Y’ALL. My perfectly seasoned plate could be Tom Colicchio’s oversalted nightmare or Padma Lakshmi’s bland palate-killer.)

And possibly it could benefit from some pepper… Not because it LACKS anything, but because, well, you LOVE pepper.

So what do you do?

Do you ask your host to pass the S&P, and sprinkle on a little of both, hoping not to hurt his feelings?

Do you again simply ignore the spice shakers and endure the meal, sans sel et poivre?

************

Spice levels are totally personal. I, for instance, like my food spicy. I’m so addicted to spice that something I find rather bland may be full-on flavorful to you. Something that needs salt in your opinion may be making me gasp for water.

It’s a variable thing.

But food is also an extremely personal thing. If I slave over a hot stove to make you dinner, and you immediately reach for the salt… well, I can’t promise I won’t feel a little twinge of hurt.

And Internet, I would never want to pass on that hurt to you by grabbing the pepper! You’re an excellent cook! I love your food! Perfectly seasoned! You’d kick Bobby Flay’s ass any day!

But when it comes to a potato. Or a salad, maybe. Or something that’s presented in a form that didn’t require your Iron Chef skills…

Well. Would you mind too horribly if I asked for the S&P?

19 thoughts on “A Spicy Question”

  1. Tricky, tricky. I am Head Chef in our household and recently got on a health quick where I reduced my intake of salt to almost ZIP. Meaning, I did not add anymore salt once I sat down at the table. At first, it was tough, but now I am used to it and actually appreciate the flavor of things, especially fresh produce.

    But, Hubs loooooooooves salt. He always looks over my shoulder as I season things during cooking and questions the (small) amount I apply. I always add more for him, but sometimes, my palette finds it salty enough where his does not. At these moments, he gets up and gets the salt (because I don’t put it on the table) and adds more = my feelings are hurt and I believe that he surely hates my food.

    Pepper on the other hand is and should be totally subjective. I could care less if anyone needs to add pepper to anything. I do not like spicy, so I totally appreciate if whoever is eating my food would like to add more.

    I would suggest that you ask for pepper in these little situations. If the host knows her etiquette, she will pass the S&P shakers together. Then, you can use the pepper to your heart’s content and dash on a bit of salt before you return the shakers to the middle of the table!
    That is what I would do!

  2. Hmm that is tricky because I am totally one of those people that would get my feelings hurt and spend the rest of the meal in a silent panic over whether or not I cooked gross food…haha!

    Maybe just ask politely for the S&P and make a joke about how you always overseason your food? Put it on you instead of making the host feel awkward?

  3. btw- my husband grew up in a household where his mother was a horrific cook. The kids all adapted by smothering every.single.thing they ate with ketchup. When we first got married, I cooked a meal for him and he promptly sat down, doused it with ketchup, and then tasted it. I could have killed him, haha!

  4. oh my, I would not mind at all. When we have people over for dinner I tend to make things less spicy than when I cook just for us, unless I know that those coming over don’t mind spicy food. I would certainly think that salting/peppering the food should not offend others, as taste is subjective. I’m also used to my best friend that salts & peppers everything (including deliciously salty japanese/chinese food & pizza!). That being said if you think the cook would/could get offended, go with what d.a.r. said and put it on yourself 🙂

  5. I wouldn’t be offended at all if you asked for or used the S&P in either situation. The potato thing, well that’s just silly to expect your guests to eat a plain potato. But I’m of the mind that if they’ve got S&P on the table, it’s there to be used. Also, I’m sorry, but I know I’m not a perfect cook and unless the person cooking for you is a chef, they shouldn’t get their panties in a bunch if you add a little salt. Taste is absolutely subjective so if I were you, salt away! (I’m with you on the pepper too — the more, the merrier.)

  6. My grandfather would frequently salt his foods liberally before even taking a bite. It wasnt meant to offend the chef, the man just loved the salt.

    One way around your situation (if the salt and pepper is on the table) is to add a dusting before you even take a bite. This way you can simply declare a love of the S&P if someone happens to question your action, without indicating that your host did not season the dish to your liking. I also dont see a problem with asking for the salt and pepper, especially if its pre-tasting.

  7. I would not be offended at all! Everyone is different and has different tastes…and you can’t please everyone. Plus, its the joy of the gathering not the food…

  8. I have definitely asked for salt at someones house and will most likely do it again. Some folks honestly forget and I’m not about to eat a bland meal to spare your feeling. eep, I don’t mean to sound cruel. I tend to put less salt in a meal so that the rest of the family can add to their hearts content. I don’t take it as rude.

  9. I LOOOOVE pepper. My DH even asked me to turn it down a notch in my recipes, so now I just have to load it up on my plate. And load.it.up. I do!

    The plain baked potato just silly! Nobody likes it PLAIN. You should never feel sorry for asking for S&P in that sort of situation.

    The second is hard. Whether or not my guests use S&P, I’m constantly worried if it’s good enough, if that was a real “mmm” or one to make me feel better. Are they chewing and not talking because it’s just so good, or it’s awful and they can hardly swallow and are dreading the next bite?

    I like the idea of you using S&P before taking a bite. I think you could also make it known to your friends that you just love S&P, like say when you are at a restaurant, make a big deal about how much you love it. Or if you are talking food with a friend, talk about how much you love it. That way when you are at their house, they won’t take it personally. My SIL DUMPS salt on all of her food, so I know not to take it personally.

  10. I actually don’t S&P my food, but it really irks me if someone does that BEFORE tasting it — like the assumption is, gee I KNOW this will taste better regardless of the fact that I haven’t tasted it. If you S&P after a bite or two, no problem.

  11. maybe first have them over to YOUR house, make dinner, pour a bunch of s+p on your dinner and talk all about how much you love them. make sure they notice and make a big deal out of it. and then when they invite you over to THEIR house, they won’t be offended 🙂 worth a shot!

  12. My husband throws salt and pepper and hot sauce on everything. Drives me nuts. I told him that salting/peppering the food I serve WITHOUT first tasting it is insulting. I never understand how people can salt/pepper something without tasting it first?! We reached the agreement that he can salt/pepper/spice anything he likes, as long as he tries it before salting. And he happily obliges, and so now I don’t use any salt in my cooking because I know he’ll add it regardless. Probably cut his intake in half! But when we go to restaurants, he always dives in with the salt/pepper without tasting it first?! So bizarre. These are professional cooks, or chefs!, you may be ruining something delicious! He is normally not a barbarian, and he thankfully never seasons his food at other people’s homes without first tasting it. That being said, as a frequent hostess (I have ppl over for dinner at least once per week) I only put salt/pepper on the table if I’m okay with people using it. I have control over my feelings, and if my feelings would be hurt, I don’t put it on the table. And I apply the same rule at other ppl’s houses. If ppl put salt/pepper on the table, it is there to use AFTER you’ve tasted the food.
    **My opinion is kinda void b.c. I never salt/pepper anything I’m served. I should start, I hear it is good 🙂

  13. I think whether you should or should not ask depends on the host’s sensitivity.

    Personally, I’d never be offended.

    I do want my hubby to enjoy/critique my cooking. I experiment with seasonings so he knows I’d like him to try it first.

  14. Well, I wouldn’t even notice if someone asked for the salt and pepper at my house. My whole family oversalts things so they ask for it allllll the time. I think people need to chill on thinking that you are “insulting” their cooking-it’s your personal preference. Puh-lease. 😀

  15. Maybe this is weird but I’d be less offended if they tried it first and then wanted salt. What I hate is if people salt before tasting, it’s like, HEY, try it how I made it first, and if you still need salt go for it! But putting salt on it first makes me think they just don’t want to taste it how I made it, but want to make it to their own taste BEFORE tasting it my way. Like, why don’t you just bring your own dinner?! Maybe I’m a little too sensitive haaaha!

Leave a Reply