Aimee Bender won me over a few years back with her incredible short-story collection, The Girl in the Flammable Skirt.
Which is why I was so eager to read Love Invents Us when I saw it on the shelf at Barnes & Noble. Unfortunately, I didn’t realize until much later that Aimee Bender is not the author of Love Invents Us. (The real author is Amy Bloom.) Luckily, I didn’t realize my mistake until after I’d devoured the book.
It was one of those books that kept me up until 3:00 am, reading and reading. It was one of those books I read in three days.
But looking back on it, I’m not quite sure why I sped through it so quickly. It’s not one of my favorite books. Despite the clean, lovely prose and the vivid depiction of the main character, I don’t even think it would make my top 50.
Mini plot summary: Elizabeth lives in a cold and not-very-loving home. She finds love with a series of questionable partners. She falls particularly hard for two men. One of them leaves her. She leaves the other. She finds them both again, to find one dying and the other married.
This book was easy to read. It was easy to love Elizabeth, the protagonist. But she was not easy to understand, at least for me. I couldn’t quite understand her motivation. You see, she doesn’t have a close relationship with her parents, and she uses sex as a way to get at the love she lacks in her home life. Understandable enough, and a theme that permeates literature and film. But the “love” she gets in return is hard to swallow. One “lover” gives her rides home from school and lets her wear fur coats. Another has her babysit for his three young sons and, ahem, pleasures her with a large electric device. Another “lover” (though not in a sexual sense) gives her beautiful old tea spoons and teaches her to cook.
I’m not sure what I came away with, once the book ended. Perhaps, the idea that love doesn’t fit some specific Hollywood ideal. That it is unique and un-asked for. That it can be transformative and beautiful. That it can be painful and sometimes ugly. Perhaps, the idea that love is enduring, even if you don’t choose it for yourself. That it persists, despite spouses or alcoholism or angry fathers or even death.
I enjoyed reading it. It had some lovely, quotable lines. And I ached for Elizabeth. Her initial “sexual” experience led her down a path that she could not deviate from, even though it sometimes repulsed her.
Should you read it? There are millions of books to read. Many of them are better and more thought-provoking than this one. But if it takes you just three nights to read… if you find yourself caught up in Elizabeth’s misguided life… if you find yourself rooting for her… if you find yourself re-reading a perfectly-phrased line a time or two… then I’d say it’s worthwhile.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on this book, if you’ve read it. Have at it in the comments – but beware that there may be spoilers.
Hmmm… I might just have to read that book to see what it’s all about.
You HAVE to read a series by Paullina Simons.
There are three books… The Bronze Horseman, Tatiana & Alexander and The Summer Garden.
I am saying you HAVE to because you will will fall in love. They are by far my three most favorite books I have ever read in my life. Seriously.
They are stories of war, strife, love, courage… oh they are just SO good.
I just ordered all three because I have to read them again. Seriously!
Any book that I can read in 3 nights is a must for me…Finding reading time is like sneaking a forbidden treat! Thanks for the post.
I haven’t read that book yet, but I’m excited to start! I think they have it at our local bookstore and I definitely want to grab a copy!
So, the first book I ever read by Amy Bloom was ‘Come to Me,’ a collection of short stories, and I thought it was beautiful. (I’d recommend it if you liked her writing style.) Actually, I think one of the short stories in it was the basis for this novel, but I might be remembering it wrong. But, anyway, so I loved that collection but I didn’t love ‘Love Invents Us.’ Actually, I didn’t even really like it all that much. I think she’s a really talented writer, but to me it kind of felt like something in the heart of the story was missing.
It’s been a while since I read it and I don’t remember it that clearly, but I’m thinking I might agree with how you didn’t really understand things all that well, in the end. Something about it felt a bit clinical to me, which I suppose would make sense because her background is in psychiatry. (Or psychology? Can’t remember.) I didn’t get a sense, really, that the author knew the characters all that well, and certainly not intimately enough that, in the end, I felt like I really knew them and was invested in them, or felt like they were real to me.
But I think you’re spot-on about the ‘message’–that seems to be kind of a theme in her work, the kind of weird iterations of love and what it can look like. It’s my own bias, but I think I prefer to read meditations on ‘love’ that are a bit more illuminating and that offer a little more grace–like Wallace Stegner, or Wendell Berry.
This is fun!! Perhaps I see some virtual book clubs in the future?